skip to main content

CenturyLink vs. EarthLink: Which Internet Provider Is Best for You?

EarthLink has variety, but CenturyLink offers no contracts and minimal fees

CenturyLink

Starting price:

$50/mo.*

Speed range:

140–940Mbps

 

 

EarthLink

Starting price:

$39.95/mo.*

Speed range:

18–5,000Mbps

View Plans for EarthLink

Compare CenturyLink and EarthLink head-to-head

CenturyLink and EarthLink both offer fiber and DSL plans, but EarthLink has an even wider range of options, including fixed wireless and 5G home internet. If you have the option for a fiber plan with either provider, that’s definitely recommended.

Services at a glance

ProviderServices
  • Fiber internet
  • DSL internet
  • EarthLink
  • Fiber internet
  • DSL internet
  • Fixed wireless
  • 5G home internet
  • Pros and cons: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    CenturyLink

    Pros

    Excellent speeds on fiber plans

    No annual contracts

    Affordable prices

    Cons

    Limited fiber availability

     

     

    EarthLink

    Pros

    Highly-rated customer support

    Expansive coverage area

    Wide range of options

    Cons

    12-month contract on fiber and DSL

    Plans and pricing: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    EarthLink wins when it comes to variety, but CenturyLink’s few plans are tried and true with the perfect amount of speed for most households. For similar technology types and speeds, CenturyLink and EarthLink charge pretty similar prices, though there is a little variation.

    CenturyLink plans and pricing

    PlanPrice*Download SpeedConnection Type
    Simply Unlimited Fiber Internet Up to 500 Mbps
    $50/mo.
    Up to 500Mbps
    Fiber
    Simply Unlimited Fiber Internet Up to 940 Mbps
    $75/mo.
    Up to 940Mbps
    Fiber
    Simply Unlimited Internet Up to 140 Mbps
    $55/mo.
    Up to 140Mbps
    DSL



    Our favorite plan: Simply Unlimited Fiber Internet Up to 500 Mbps

    Fiber is the best internet connection technology you can get, and 500Mbps is more than enough speed for online gaming and streaming on multiple devices. See our methodology for more information.

    CenturyLink’s plans may be limited, but it has the classics. Speeds of 500 to 940Mbps is plenty for online gaming, video conferencing, and surfing the web across multiple devices. For areas where fiber isn’t available, you also have the choice of DSL. It’s slower than the fiber plans, but great for light internet browsing.

    EarthLink plans and pricing

    PlanPrice*Download SpeedConnection Type
    $64.95/mo.
    Up to 18Mbps
    DSL
    $64.95/mo.
    Up to 24Mbps
    DSL
    $64.95/mo.
    Up to 45Mbps
    DSL
    $64.95/mo.
    Up to 75Mbps
    DSL
    $59.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fixed Wireless
    $84.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fixed Wireless
    $109.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fixed Wireless
    $159.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fixed Wireless
    $39.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fixed Wireless
    $39.95/mo.
    Up to 100Mbps
    Fiber
    $49.95/mo.
    Up to 300Mbps
    Fiber
    $69.95/mo.
    Up to 500Mbps
    Fiber
    $79.95/mo.
    Up to 1,000Mbps
    Fiber
    $109.95/mo.
    Up to 2,000Mbps
    Fiber
    $149.95/mo.
    Up to 5,000Mbps
    Fiber
    $79.95/mo.
    Up to 425Mbps
    5G Home Internet
    $79.95/mo.
    Up to 25Mbps
    Fixed Wireless



    Our favorite plan: Fiber 300

    300Mbps is plenty of fiber for a household of four to simultaneously stay online through streaming, gaming, and video conferencing. See our methodology for more information.

    You have your pick of the litter when it comes to technology types with EarthLink. Opting for fiber, fixed wireless, or 5G home internet is highly recommended, but DSL is also a great option if your internet needs are minimal and you’re in an area that fiber doesn’t reach.

    Deals and promotions: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    Free Install & WiFi
    Free Install & WiFi

    Get free install and Wi-Fi gear with CenturyLink 940Mbps internet. Terms apply

    No Bundles, No Surprises
    No Bundles, No Surprises

    No deals or bundles here, but visit Earthlink for sweet local deals.

    Up-front costs: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    CenturyLink doesn’t charge for activation, but EarthLink does on the fixed wireless plans. Not getting EarthLink fixed wireless? Then the only thing you’ll need to worry about is the installation fee.

    Installation cost

    Installation fee

    CenturyLink

  • $25 self-installation kit for DSL
  • $129 professional installation for DSL
  • Free professional installation for fiber plans
  • EarthLink

  • $79.95 professional installation for fiber and DSL
  • Pay only shipping and handling for self-installation
  • $79.95 activation fee for fixed wireless
  • Professional installation and self-installation are available with both providers, though it will cost a bit more with CenturyLink if you’re getting a DSL plan. Fiber professional installation is free with CenturyLink, but will cost a fee with EarthLink.

    Want to know if CenturyLink or EarthLink is in your area?

    Find out if CenturyLink and EarthLink are available where you live by entering your zip code below.

    Recurring fees: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    Equipment feeOther fees

    CenturyLink

  • $17/mo. equipment fee for DSL plans
  • No fee for fiber plans
  • Up to $200 for non-returned equipment
  • Late fees
  • EarthLink

  • $12.95/mo. equipment fee
  • Up to $200 early termination fee
  • Fiber equipment is free at CenturyLink, but DSL equipment will cost a fee.

    EarthLink charges a monthly equipment fee, and you’ll have to sign up for a 12-month contract if you’re getting DSL or fiber, and breaking that contract will come with a hefty termination fee.

    Price hikes

    Neither CenturyLink nor EarthLink hikes their prices at a set time—not even after your 12-month contract period ends. You can expect to see occasional increases on your bill as the cost of living increases, but these are rare, and CenturyLink will notify you at least 30 days in advance.

    Ready to switch to CenturyLink or EarthLink?

    Enter your zip code below to see if these two providers are available to you.

    Final call: CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    CenturyLink is our favorite. With no contracts, no fiber installation and equipment fees, and great options for speed at a low price, it is a clear winner if you can get on fiber. Can’t get on fiber with CenturyLink? EarthLink is a great choice with a variety of options to choose from.

    FAQ about CenturyLink vs. EarthLink

    Does CenturyLink have data caps?

    Which is better for gaming—CenturyLink or EarthLink?

    Is there an activation fee for EarthLink?

    Methodology

    Our HighSpeedInternet.com editorial team bases our analyses on customer input from our Annual Internet Service Provider Review, results from our speed test tool, and proprietary internet provider data on speeds and pricing. To strengthen our research, we look closely at provider contracts to get hard-to-find information on price hikes, data caps, and extra fees, and we keep tabs on the latest news reports and online reviews. When applicable, we also rely on our personal experiences testing these services.

    Our favorite plan

    The average household needs internet speeds of at least 300Mbps but not more than a gig (1,000Mbps), so the best plan we recommend for each provider is always within that range. We also consider plan specifics, like added costs or included perks, and compare all the options from each provider to national averages. Finally, we account for tech type differences, since you might not need as much speed on a fiber plan as you would on a less-reliable fixed wireless or cable plan. Learn more about how much speed you need, and enter your zip code in our provider lookup tool to see what you can get in your neighborhood.

    A note about pricing

    The prices you see may not reflect the standard rates these providers could charge after an introductory period. You’ll see the standard rates on broadband nutrition labels displayed during checkout, along with equipment fees, installation fees, contract requirements, and data caps (if any). Always view this information before you sign up for internet service.

    Plans disclaimers

    Deals Disclaimers

    Author -

    Editor - Jessica Brooksby

    Jessica loves bringing her passion for the written word and her love of tech into one space at HighSpeedInternet.com. She works with the team’s writers to revise strong, user-focused content so every reader can find the tech that works for them. Jessica has a bachelor’s degree in English from Utah Valley University and seven years of creative and editorial experience. Outside of work, she spends her time gaming, reading, painting, and buying an excessive amount of Legend of Zelda merchandise.