skip to main content

NordVPN vs. Private Internet Access: Which VPN Is Better?

NordVPN

Starting price:

$3.49/mo.*

View Plans for NordVPN

Compare NordVPN and Private Internet Access head-to-head

Which VPN is better, NordVPN or Private Internet Access? For most people, it’s Private Internet Access (PIA). It gives you every feature in a single plan, covers unlimited devices, has apps without the constant upsells, and costs less. NordVPN fights back with stronger raw speeds, a deeper bundle of identity protection tools, and a privacy record that’s held up against real government pressure.

That’s the short version. We used both as our everyday VPN, and the longer version will help you decide which is best for you.

Overall, PIA comes out on top, 85/100 to NordVPN’s 77/100. For the deep dives, check out our NordVPN review and Private Internet Access review. For the head-to-head, here’s how these two trusted VPNs compare.

NordVPN vs. Private Internet Access at a glance

NordVPNPrivate Internet Access
Overall score77/10085/100
Starting price$3.49/mo. (Basic)$1.33/mo. (3-yr. plan)
Month-to-month price$14.99/mo.$11.95/mo.
Entry plan renewal$139.08/yr.$47.88/yr. (1-yr. plan)
Free planNoNo
Servers9,400+ in 111 countries29,000+ in 91 countries
Simultaneous devices10Unlimited
Money-back guarantee30 days30 days (direct purchases only)
Company backgroundLaunched 2012; Panama headquartersLaunched 2010; Denver, Colorado headquarters; owned by Kape Technologies since 2019

Pricing: PIA gives you more for less

This one isn’t close. PIA is cheaper month to month, cheaper on its long-term plans, and far simpler to buy. There’s only one plan, and it includes every feature PIA offers. The only decision you have to make is how long you want to commit.

NordVPN goes the other direction. Its month-to-month rate is among the highest of any VPN, and the extras you might want are spread across three tiers that get pricier as you climb. Price hikes are part of the deal too. Our billing page was already showing a 37% increase for when our two-year contract renews. You’d think two years of loyalty would earn you a break, right? Not with Nord.

Here’s what each plan costs and what you get.

PlanPrice rangeRenewal rateWhat's included
PIA VPN$2.03–$11.95/mo.$11.95/mo.
  • Every feature
  • Unlimited devices
  • NordVPN Basic$3.49-$14.99/mo.$139.08/yr.
  • 10 devices
  • Scam and phishing protection
  • Dark web monitor
  • Nord Complete$4.49-$19.99/mo.$219.48/yr.
  • Basic plan features
  • Antivirus
  • Password manager
  • Cloud storage
  • Scam call protection
  • Nord Prime$7.49-$29.99/mo.$296.28/yr.
  • Complete plan features
  • Credit monitoring
  • Identity theft and cyber extortion insurance
  • Speed and performance: It’s a tie

    These two earned the exact same speed score from us, but they get there in opposite ways. NordVPN held onto more of our bandwidth, barely denting downloads and uploads. PIA gave up more raw speed but kept latency and jitter low, posting one of the best jitter results we’ve ever recorded. In daily use, that showed. We barely noticed PIA was running, while Nord gave us shifting audio delays during work meetings.

    Local server resultNordVPNPIAWinner
    Download speed890Mbps (-5.3%)732Mbps (-22.2%)NordVPN
    Upload speed909Mbps (-4.1%)749Mbps (-21.0%)NordVPN
    Latency110.94 ms (+332%)50.28 ms (+96%)PIA
    Jitter33.92 ms (+910%)7.61 ms (+126%)PIA

    A quick note on distant servers: On a far-off server, ExpressVPN held up better across the board, with faster downloads and uploads and less lag than PIA.

    What does that mean for you? If you download big files or connect to servers overseas, ExpressVPN is the better pick. If you game on nearby servers, PIA’s steadier connection gives it a slight edge.

    Features: Nord builds a security suite, PIA perfects the VPN

    Both cover the essentials, so you won’t go without on either one. Each offers a kill switch, split tunneling, ad and malicious site blocking, multiple protocols, obfuscation to hide that you’re using a VPN, and help getting around age verification and regional blocks. Both also sell a dedicated IP as an add-on.

    Where they split is the philosophy. NordVPN builds outward into an all-in-one security suite, with post-quantum encryption, dark web monitoring, and, on higher tiers, antivirus, a password manager, cloud storage, and identity theft insurance. PIA stays focused on the VPN itself and gives you more control over it. You can choose between two encryption strengths, route your traffic through two servers with multi-hop, and turn on an advanced kill switch that blocks all traffic until the VPN is on. Its split tunneling even finds your apps for you, while Nord makes you dig through your program files.

    Pick the approach that fits you. Want one subscription for your whole online security setup? Go Nord. Want a powerful, no-nonsense VPN? Go PIA.

    Security and privacy: PIA for transparency, NordVPN under pressure

    Let’s be clear: Both are safe choices. Each uses AES-256 encryption, runs RAM-only servers that can’t store your data long-term, and has a no-logs policy verified by third-party audits.

    PIA earned a perfect security score from us, and transparency is why. Deloitte has confirmed its no-logs policy three times, most recently in 2026, and PIA lets anyone read the audit report, not just paying customers. Its code is 100% open source, so anyone can check it for weaknesses.

    NordVPN has something you can’t put on a spec sheet. It’s passed third-party audits for 14 years, and it has walked away from entire countries rather than compromise. In 2019, it shut down its Russian servers instead of following a government blocklist. In 2022, it did the same in India rather than store user data for five years. If proven backbone matters most to you, that record is hard to beat.

    Apps: PIA is easier to use

    This is PIA’s biggest win. Its app uses every inch of the screen for things you actually need: a big connect button, your server and IP addresses, and a live ping for every server so you can pick the fastest one at a glance. Expand it, and you get quick-connect options, usage stats, and the status of your key settings. There are no upsells anywhere.

    NordVPN’s apps are stable, but frequent upsells crowd the screen, and the features you actually need, like split tunneling and protocol settings, are buried in the settings menu. There’s no ping or performance info either.

    PIA also brings the bigger network, with more than three times as many servers, though Nord reaches more countries. And PIA covers unlimited devices, with apps for nearly every smart TV, from Roku to Samsung. Nord caps you at 10 devices, which could pinch a busy household.

    Billing and cancellation: A tie, for different reasons

    Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, both paid up, and both earned the same billing score. The trade-offs are just different. With NordVPN, everything lives right in the app, but getting our refund meant chatting with support, verifying our identity, and waiting on a live agent to fix a missing refund button. With PIA, the process was painless once it got moving, but slower to start. We filed a support ticket, waited about a day for a reply, and had our refund within hours of confirming. PIA didn’t even make us give a reason. Here’s how the two compare.

    NordVPNPIA
    How to request a refundLive chat, then ID verificationSupport ticket or email
    Billing in the app?YesNo, website only
    Our reviewer's experienceRefund button missing; a live agent fixed itReply in about 24 hours, no issues
    Refund timingAbout 2 hours to appear in the accountAbout 8 hours after confirming

    Pro tip: Buy PIA directly from its website. Subscriptions purchased through app stores don’t qualify for its money-back guarantee.

    Final verdict for NordVPN vs. Private Internet Access: PIA wins!

    PIA takes it, 85/100 to 77/100. It wins where you’ll feel it most: price, apps, and peace of mind, with one plan that covers everything and every device you own. Nord matched it on speed and billing but didn’t win a single category outright.

    NordVPN is still a strong pick if you want faster downloads, a full security suite with identity theft insurance, or a privacy record that’s been tested by real governments. For everyone else, PIA gives you more VPN for less, without the upsells.

    NordVPN vs. Private Internet Access: FAQ

    Is NordVPN or PIA faster?

    Which is cheaper, NordVPN or PIA?

    Do NordVPN or PIA have a free plan?

    How many devices can I connect?

    Which VPN has more servers?

    Disclaimers

    Author -

    Editor - Jessica Brooksby

    Jessica loves bringing her passion for the written word and her love of tech into one space at HighSpeedInternet.com. She works with the team’s writers to revise strong, user-focused content so every reader can find the tech that works for them. Jessica has a bachelor’s degree in English from Utah Valley University and seven years of creative and editorial experience. Outside of work, she spends her time gaming, reading, painting, and buying an excessive amount of Legend of Zelda merchandise.