Private Internet Access vs. IPVanish: Which VPN Is Better?
Nov 19, 2026 | Share
Security, VPN Vs.
Compare Private Internet Access and IPVanish head-to-head
Which VPN is better, Private Internet Access or IPVanish? The easy answer for most is Private Internet Access (PIA) because it costs less, earns a perfect security score, runs a server network more than eight times the size, and has apps without the upsells. IPVanish also makes a strong case, with 24/7 phone support, a lightning-fast refund process, and a long list of extra security tools. And whichever you pick, you’ll get unlimited devices on every plan.
But you can read that anywhere. We actually tested both of these providers, and here’s how it nets out.
Overall, our research gives PIA the nod in scoring, coming in at 85/100 to IPVanish’s 70/100. For more, check out our Private Internet Access and IPVanish reviews. For the true head-to-head comparison, here’s how these two top-notch VPNs compare.
Private Internet Access vs. IPVanish at a glance
| Private Internet Access | IPVanish | |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 85/100 | 70/100 |
| Starting price | $1.33/mo. (3-yr. plan) | $2.39/mo. |
| Month-to-month price | $11.95/mo. | $14.99/mo. |
| Free plan | No | No |
| Servers | 29,000+ in 91 countries | 3,400 in 113 countries |
| Simultaneous devices | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days (direct purchases only) | 30 days |
| Company background | Launched 2010; Denver, Colorado headquarters; owned by Kape Technologies since 2019 | Launched 2012; U.S. headquarters; owned by Ziff Davis since 2019 |
Availability and speed may vary by location, and prices are subject to change. See disclaimers.
In this comparison:
Pricing | Speed and performance | Features | Security and privacy | Apps | Billing and cancellation | Final verdict | FAQ
In this comparison:
Pricing: PIA gives you more for less
This one is obvious: PIA wins on price. It’s cheaper month to month, cheaper on its long-term plans, and far simpler to buy. There’s only one plan, and it includes every feature PIA offers. Even better, PIA renews at the same rate you signed up for.
IPVanish splits its extras across three tiers, though the gap between them is small, and every plan includes travel eSIM data. Its post-promo price hikes are steep, and our account didn’t show what we’d pay at renewal at all. You’d think a VPN would be up front about what you’ll pay next, right? Not here. Both cover unlimited devices on every plan, so there’s no catch there.
Here are the renewal rates you can expect if you commit to either of them.
| Plan | Price range | Renewal rate | What's included |
|---|---|---|---|
| PIA VPN | $1.33–$11.95/mo. | $11.95/mo. | |
| IPVanish Essential | $2.19-$12.99/mo. | $89.99/yr. | |
| IPVanish Complete | $3.09–$14.99/mo. | Disclosed by email before renewal | |
| IPVanish Advanced | $3.29-$17.99/mo. | $109.99/yr. |
* Availability and speed may vary by location, and prices are subject to change. See disclaimers.
Speed and performance: PIA by a nose
PIA earned the higher speed score, but this one is closer than the scores suggest. On a nearby server, IPVanish actually kept more download speed and added slightly less lag, while PIA held onto more upload speed.
Both kept connections steady, with some of the lowest jitter we’ve recorded, and both handled our everyday video calls with barely a hiccup. Here’s the speed breakdown so you can see where each one wins.
| Local server result | PIA | IPVanish | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Download speed | 732Mbps (-22.2%) | 860Mbps (-8.5%) | IPVanish |
| Upload speed | 749Mbps (-21.0%) | 700Mbps (-26.2%) | PIA |
| Latency | 50.28 ms (+96%) | 47.3 ms (+84.3%) | IPVanish |
| Jitter | 7.61 ms (+126%) | 6.6 ms (+96.4%) | IPVanish |
A quick note on distant servers: On a far-off server, IPVanish kept more download speed with less lag, while PIA kept more upload speed.
What does that mean for you? For everyday browsing, streaming, and video calls, you’ll be happy with either one. If you download big files, IPVanish has a slight edge.
Features: PIA perfects the VPN, IPVanish piles on security tools
PIA and IPVanish have more in common than most pairs we’ve compared. Both cover unlimited devices on every plan and include split tunneling, ad and tracker blocking, a way to route your traffic through two servers, a choice of protocols, and help getting around age-verification and regional blocks.
Where they split is the philosophy. PIA stays focused on the VPN itself and gives you more control over it. You can choose between two encryption strengths, hide the fact you’re using a VPN with obfuscation, and turn on an advanced kill switch that blocks all traffic until the VPN is on, all on its one plan. Its split tunneling even finds your apps for you.
IPVanish piles on everyday security tools. Every plan includes travel eSIM data, a link checker for suspicious URLs, a QR code scanner, and a password generator, and its higher plans add antivirus, phone support, ransomware protection, a secure browser, and 1TB each of cloud storage and backup.
The unique offerings won’t change how either VPN protects you day to day. If you want a powerful, no-nonsense VPN, go PIA. If you want cloud storage, phone support, and a grab bag of security tools, go IPVanish.
Security and privacy: PIA is the safer bet
Let’s be clear: Both PIA and IPVanish are reliable choices. Each uses AES-256 encryption and has a no-logs policy verified by independent audits. Both are also headquartered in the U.S. and part of bigger companies: PIA has been owned by Kape Technologies since 2019, and IPVanish has been owned by Ziff Davis since 2019.
What sets PIA ahead is transparency. It earned a perfect security score from us. Deloitte has confirmed its no-logs policy three times, most recently in 2026, and PIA lets anyone read the audit report, not just paying customers. Its RAM-only servers can’t store your data long-term, and its code is 100% open source, so anyone can check it for weaknesses.
IPVanish has a bit more baggage. In 2016, under previous ownership, it handed user logs to U.S. authorities during a criminal investigation. There hasn’t been another incident since, and its most recent independent audit in 2025 confirmed it doesn’t store your activity or original IP address. Still, if privacy is your top priority, that history is worth knowing.
Apps: PIA is far easier to use
PIA’s app earned a perfect score from us. It uses every inch of the screen for things you actually need: a big connect button, your server and IP addresses, and a live ping for every server so you can pick the fastest one at a glance. There are no upsells anywhere.
IPVanish’s app gave us trouble from the start. On our Mac, the connect button simply didn’t work, with no error message, and it took a bot, a live agent, and a switch to the IKEv2 protocol before we could get online. Once it was running, it was usable, but you can’t search for locations from the home screen, and there’s nothing to tell you which server is fastest.
Billing and cancellation: IPVanish makes it painless
Both providers offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, and both paid up. The difference was how long it took. With IPVanish, we canceled and got our refund processed right from our online account in about two minutes, without talking to anyone, and the cancel screen even told us we were eligible.
With PIA, we filed a support ticket and waited about a day for a reply. Once PIA got back to us, the refund came quickly, and it didn’t even make us give a reason. Check out the step-by-step breakdown for cancellation below.
| PIA | IPVanish | |
|---|---|---|
| How to request a refund | Support ticket or email | Self-serve in your online account |
| Our reviewer's experience | Reply in about 24 hours, no reason required | Canceled and refunded in a few clicks, no issues |
| Refund timing | About 8 hours after confirming | Processed in about two minutes |
Pro tip: Buy PIA directly from its website, since app store purchases don’t qualify for its money-back guarantee. With IPVanish, set a reminder before your first term ends, since your account won’t show your renewal price.
Final verdict for Private Internet Access vs. IPVanish: PIA wins!
Yes, PIA wins overall, 85/100 to 70/100. It led six of seven categories, with its biggest edges in security, servers, and apps. IPVanish’s only outright win was billing, thanks to its lightning-fast self-serve refund.

IPVanish is a strong pick if you want 24/7 phone support, the quickest refund process around, or cloud storage and backup bundled in. For everyone else, PIA gives you more VPN for less, a stronger privacy record, and an app that just works.
Private Internet Access vs. IPVanish: FAQ
Is PIA or IPVanish faster?
Which is cheaper, PIA or IPVanish?
Do PIA or IPVanish have a free plan?
Can I use PIA or IPVanish for streaming?
Disclaimers
Prices and plan offerings are accurate as of July 2026. We update VPN pricing data on a quarterly basis in order to compare providers fairly and to present stable pricing expectations. VPN services update prices frequently, so plans, prices, and offers may vary based on when you order.
IPVanish plans
IPVanish Essential – By clicking the subscribe button you agree to be charged $56.48. After your first term, your plan will automatically renew annually at $89.99 until canceled through your IPVanish account. By signing up with IPVanish, you agree to our Terms of Service, including mandatory arbitration, and the Privacy Policy.
IPVanish Advanced — By clicking the subscribe button you agree to be charged $84.84. After your first term, your plan will automatically renew annually at $109.99 until canceled through your IPVanish account. By signing up with IPVanish, you agree to our Terms of Service, including mandatory arbitration, and the Privacy Policy.
Private Internet Access plans
All plans — All amounts are shown in USD, and any discounts reflect a reduction based on the current monthly service pricing at $11.95 per month. The 30-day money-back guarantee is available to new subscribers only; for subscriptions purchased via third-party app stores (e.g., Apple App Store), refunds are subject to their respective terms and conditions.
Author -
Editor - Jessica Brooksby
Jessica loves bringing her passion for the written word and her love of tech into one space at HighSpeedInternet.com. She works with the team’s writers to revise strong, user-focused content so every reader can find the tech that works for them. Jessica has a bachelor’s degree in English from Utah Valley University and seven years of creative and editorial experience. Outside of work, she spends her time gaming, reading, painting, and buying an excessive amount of Legend of Zelda merchandise.




