skip to main content

Private Internet Access vs. CyberGhost: Which VPN Is Better?

Cyberghost

Starting price:

$1.59/mo.*

View Plans for Cyberghost

Compare Private Internet Access and CyberGhost head-to-head

Which VPN is better, Private Internet Access or CyberGhost? This is the closest race we’ve ever scored. The easy answer for most is CyberGhost because it’s faster, makes getting a refund painless, and it has servers built for streaming and gaming. Private Internet Access (PIA) also makes a strong case, with a lower price, unlimited devices, and a perfect security score.

But you can read that anywhere. We actually tested both of these providers, and here’s how it nets out.

Overall, our research gives CyberGhost the nod, but just barely. Both round to 85/100, and when you add up every category point, CyberGhost comes out ahead by less than one point. For more, check out our Private Internet Access and CyberGhost reviews. For the true head-to-head comparison, here’s how these two top-notch VPNs compare.

Private Internet Access vs. CyberGhost at a glance

Private Internet AccessCyberGhost
Overall score85/10085.4/100
Starting price$1.33/mo. (3-yr. plan)$1.59/mo.
Month-to-month price$11.95/mo.$12.99/mo.
Free planNoNo
Servers29,000+ in 91 countries11,500+ in 100 countries
Simultaneous devicesUnlimited7
Money-back guarantee30 days (direct purchases only)45 days (14 days on monthly plans)
Company backgroundLaunched 2010; Denver, Colorado headquarters; owned by Kape Technologies since 2019Launched 2011; Bucharest, Romania headquarters; owned by Kape Technologies since 2017

Pricing: PIA by a nose

These two take the same refreshing approach to pricing: one plan with every feature, so the only choice you make is how long to commit. No upsells, no tiers to compare. PIA edges ahead because it’s a little cheaper both monthly and on its long-term deal. It renews at the same rate you signed up for, and it covers unlimited devices, compared to CyberGhost’s seven.

CyberGhost has a strong pricing story of its own. Our reviewer has used it for seven years and has never seen a price hike. It also gives you longer to change your mind, with a 45-day money-back guarantee on plans of six months or more.

Here are the renewal rates you can expect if you commit to either of them.

PlanPrice rangeRenewal rateWhat's included
PIA VPN$1.33–$11.95/mo.$11.95/mo.
  • Unlimited devices
  • Split tunneling
  • Ad and malicious site blocker
  • Multi-hop
  • CyberGhost$1.59–$12.99/mo.$12.99/mo.
  • Up to 7 devices
  • Ad and malware blocker
  • Streaming servers
  • Privacy Guard
  • Speed and performance: CyberGhost pulls ahead

    CyberGhost is one of the fastest VPNs we’ve tested, and it beats PIA on every measurement on a nearby server. It held onto far more of our download and upload speed and added even less lag, low enough that gaming and video calls ran just as they would without a VPN.

    PIA is no slouch. It posted one of the best jitter results we’ve recorded, and we barely noticed it was running. CyberGhost just did it with more speed to spare. Here’s the speed breakdown so you can see why.

    Local server resultPIACyberGhostWinner
    Download speed732Mbps (-22.2%)887Mbps (-5.6%)CyberGhost
    Upload speed749Mbps (-21.0%)885Mbps (-6.6%)CyberGhost
    Latency50.28 ms (+96%)33.15 ms (+29%)CyberGhost
    Jitter7.61 ms (+126%)5.1 ms (+52%)CyberGhost

    A quick note on distant servers: On a far-off server, CyberGhost held up better, too, with faster downloads and noticeably less lag than PIA.

    What does that mean for you? If speed is your top priority, whether you’re gaming, downloading big files, or connecting overseas, CyberGhost is the better pick. PIA’s speeds are still plenty for everyday browsing, streaming, and video calls.

    Features: Two no-nonsense VPNs with different strengths

    PIA and CyberGhost share a philosophy: Focus on the VPN itself and put every feature in every plan. Both offer a kill switch, split tunneling, ad blocking, multiple protocols, RAM-only servers, and help getting around age-verification and regional blocks.

    Where they split is what they focus on. PIA is built for control. You can choose between two encryption strengths, route your traffic through two servers with multi-hop, hide the fact you’re using a VPN with obfuscation, and turn on an advanced kill switch that blocks all traffic until the VPN is on. Its split tunneling even finds your apps for you.

    CyberGhost is built for convenience. It has servers made for specific streaming services and gaming, extra-private NoSpy servers, and Privacy Guard, which tightens the privacy settings on your computer and browsers. It also works with just about anything, from Roku to PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo Switch. One knock against CyberGhost: On computers, split tunneling only works for websites, not apps.

    The unique offerings won’t change how either VPN protects you day to day. If you want to fine-tune your VPN and cover unlimited devices, go PIA. If you want a VPN that’s ready for streaming and gaming out of the box, go CyberGhost.

    Security and privacy: PIA by a hair

    Let’s be clear: Both PIA and CyberGhost are safe choices when it comes to security and privacy. Each uses AES-256 encryption, runs RAM-only servers that can’t store your data long-term, and has had its no-logs policy confirmed by Deloitte three times. They’re even owned by the same company, Kape Technologies, so the one asterisk applies to both: Kape’s past issues with ad and malware distribution raised some eyebrows when it bought these brands.

    What sets PIA slightly ahead is transparency. It earned a perfect security score from us, lets anyone read its Deloitte audit report, not just paying customers, and its code is 100% open source, so anyone can check it for weaknesses.

    CyberGhost earns its trust through consistency. Our reviewer has relied on it every day for seven years without a hitch. You can also pick from three protocols or let CyberGhost choose the best one for whatever you’re doing.

    Apps: It’s a tie

    Both apps earned a perfect score from us, and both are refreshingly free of upsells. PIA uses every inch of the screen for things you actually need, including a live ping for every server so you can pick the fastest one at a glance.

    CyberGhost puts everything a click or two away, uses a bright yellow button and tray icon to show at a glance when you’re protected, and lets you sort servers by distance. It only shows pings for its gaming servers, though, so PIA is the better pick if you like choosing your own server.

    Billing and cancellation: CyberGhost is smoother

    CyberGhost makes leaving almost as easy as signing up. There’s a dedicated cancel button right on your subscription page, and its 24/7 live chat got our refund underway in less than five minutes.

    With PIA, we had to file a support ticket and wait about a day for a reply. Once PIA got back to us, the refund came quickly, and it didn’t even make us give a reason.

    CyberGhost also gives you longer to change your mind, with 45 days on plans of six months or more, compared to PIA’s 30. Check out the step-by-step breakdown for cancellation below.

    PIACyberGhost
    How to request a refundSupport ticket or email24/7 live chat, email, or support ticket
    Our reviewer's experienceReply in about 24 hours, no reason requiredA few retention questions, no issues
    Refund timingAbout 8 hours after confirmingStarted in less than five minutes

    Pro tip: Buy either VPN directly from its website, since app store purchases don’t qualify for either money-back guarantee. With CyberGhost, choose the six-month or two-year plan for the full 45 days, since the monthly plan only gives you 14.

    Final verdict for Private Internet Access vs. CyberGhost: CyberGhost wins!

    Yes, CyberGhost wins, but it’s the closest call we’ve ever made. Both VPNs round to 85/100, and when you add up every category point, CyberGhost edges out PIA 85.4 to 84.8, a margin of just 0.6 points. The two split the categories almost evenly: CyberGhost won on billing, servers, and speed, PIA won on price, security, and devices, and they tied on apps. What tipped it was CyberGhost’s big lead in speed and billing, the things you’ll notice every day.

    PIA is a strong pick, and honestly a near-equal one, if you want the lowest long-term price, coverage for unlimited devices, a perfect security score, and the most control over your VPN. For everyone else, CyberGhost gives you faster speeds, the easiest refund process, and servers ready for streaming and gaming out of the box.

    Private Internet Access vs. CyberGhost: FAQ

    Is PIA or CyberGhost faster?

    Which is cheaper, PIA or CyberGhost?

    Do PIA or CyberGhost have a free plan?

    Can I use PIA or CyberGhost for streaming?

    Disclaimers

    Author -

    Editor - Jessica Brooksby

    Jessica loves bringing her passion for the written word and her love of tech into one space at HighSpeedInternet.com. She works with the team’s writers to revise strong, user-focused content so every reader can find the tech that works for them. Jessica has a bachelor’s degree in English from Utah Valley University and seven years of creative and editorial experience. Outside of work, she spends her time gaming, reading, painting, and buying an excessive amount of Legend of Zelda merchandise.