skip to main content

Surfshark vs. Private Internet Access: Which VPN Is Better?

Surfshark

Starting price:

$2.49/mo.*

View Plans for Surfshark

Compare Surfshark and Private Internet Access head-to-head

Which VPN is better, Surfshark or Private Internet Access? The easy answer for most is Private Internet Access (PIA) because it costs less, runs one of the biggest server networks we’ve tested, keeps connections steadier for calls and gaming, and has apps without the upsells. Surfshark also makes a strong case, with faster raw speeds and a bundle of extra privacy and identity tools.

But you can read that anywhere. We actually tested both of these providers, and here’s how it nets out.

Overall, our research gives PIA the nod in scoring, coming in at 85/100 to Surfshark’s 74.7/100. For more, check out our Surfshark and Private Internet Access reviews. For the true head-to-head comparison, here’s how these two top-notch VPNs compare.

Surfshark vs. Private Internet Access at a glance

SurfsharkPrivate Internet Access
Overall score74.7/10085/100
Starting price$2.49/mo. (Starter)$1.33/mo.
Month-to-month price$16.45/mo.$11.95/mo.
Free planNoNo
Servers4,500 in 100 countries29,000+ in 91 countries
Simultaneous devicesUnlimitedUnlimited
Money-back guarantee30 days30 days (direct purchases only)
Company backgroundLaunched 2018; Amsterdam, Netherlands headquarters; merged with Nord Security in 2022Launched 2010; Denver, Colorado headquarters; owned by Kape Technologies since 2019

Pricing: PIA gives you more for less

This one is obvious: PIA wins on price. It’s cheaper month to month, cheaper on its long-term plans, and far simpler to buy. There’s only one plan, and it includes every feature PIA offers on unlimited devices. Even better, PIA renews at the same rate you signed up for.

Surfshark’s month-to-month rate is the highest of any major VPN we’ve compared, and its extras are spread across three tiers. To be fair, its entry-level Starter plan still packs in advanced tools like double VPN, a rotating IP, and unlimited devices. But Surfshark doesn’t spell out its renewal rate at all, only that you’ll pay its then-current price. You’d think a VPN would be up front about what you’ll pay next, right? Not here.

Here are the renewal rates you can expect if you commit to either of them.

PlanPrice rangeRenewal rateWhat's included
Surfshark Starter$2.49-$16.45/mo.Disclosed at renewal
  • Unlimited devices
  • Ad and pop-up blocker
  • Split tunneling
  • Rotating IP
  • Double VPN
  • Alternative ID
  • Surfshark One$2.79-$18.95/mo.Disclosed at renewal
  • All Starter plan features
  • Scam text and email protection
  • Antivirus
  • Data leak alerts
  • Content blocker
  • Surfshark One+$4.49-$21.86/mo.Disclosed at renewal
  • All One plan features
  • Identity theft coverage
  • Incogni data removal
  • PIA VPN$1.33–$11.95/mo.$11.95/mo.
  • Unlimited devices
  • Split tunneling
  • Ad and malicious site blocker
  • Multi-hop
  • Speed and performance: PIA by a hair

    These two earned nearly identical speed scores, but they got there in opposite ways. Surfshark is one of the fastest VPNs we’ve tested for raw bandwidth, barely denting our downloads and uploads. But it added a lot of lag, and our video calls were noticeably delayed and choppy.

    PIA gave up more raw speed but kept latency low and posted one of the best jitter results we’ve ever recorded, so we barely noticed it was running. Here’s the speed breakdown so you can see why it was so close.

    Local server resultSurfsharkPIAWinner
    Download speed870Mbps (-7.4%)732Mbps (-22.2%)Surfshark
    Upload speed909Mbps (-4.1%)749Mbps (-21.0%)Surfshark
    Latency130 ms (+407%)50.28 ms (+96%)PIA
    Jitter38 ms (+1,031%)7.61 ms (+126%)PIA

    A quick note on distant servers: On a far-off server, Surfshark held up better, with faster downloads and less lag than PIA.

    What does that mean for you? If you download big files or connect to servers overseas, Surfshark is the better pick. If you game or live on video calls, PIA’s steadier connection will serve you better.

    Features: Surfshark builds a privacy bundle; PIA perfects the VPN

    Surfshark and PIA have more in common than most pairs we’ve compared. Both cover unlimited devices, offer a kill switch, split tunneling, ad blocking, a way to route your traffic through two servers, and help you get around age-verification and regional blocks. Both also sell a dedicated IP and antivirus, though Surfshark bundles antivirus into its higher tiers while PIA sells it as an add-on.

    Where they split is the philosophy. Surfshark builds outward into a privacy bundle, with post-quantum protection, an IP address that rotates every five minutes, and Alternative ID for signing up online without your real details. Its higher plans add data leak alerts, identity theft coverage, Incogni data removal, and a content blocker you can lock with two-factor authentication.

    PIA stays focused on the VPN itself and gives you more control over it, with obfuscation, a choice of encryption strengths, and an advanced kill switch that blocks all traffic until the VPN is on, all on its one plan.

    The unique offerings won’t change how either VPN protects you day to day. If you want identity protection and family tools in one subscription, go Surfshark. If you want a powerful, no-nonsense VPN, go PIA.

    Security and privacy: It’s a tie

    Let’s be clear: Both Surfshark and PIA are safe choices, and both earned a perfect security score from us. Each uses AES-256 encryption, runs RAM-only servers that can’t store your data long-term, and has a no-logs policy confirmed by Deloitte. Both are also part of bigger companies: Surfshark merged with Nord Security, NordVPN’s parent company, in 2022, and PIA has been owned by Kape Technologies since 2019.

    Surfshark’s strength is that it doesn’t hold anything back. Even its entry-level plan includes double VPN, a rotating IP, split tunneling, and a kill switch. Deloitte has confirmed its no-logs policy twice, though you’ll need an account to read those reports.

    PIA’s strength is transparency. Deloitte has confirmed its no-logs policy three times, most recently in 2026, and PIA lets anyone read the audit report, not just paying customers. Its code is 100% open source, too, so anyone can check it for weaknesses.

    Apps: PIA is easier to use

    PIA’s app earned a perfect score from us. It uses every inch of the screen for things you actually need: a big connect button, your server and IP addresses, and a live ping for every server so you can pick the fastest one at a glance. There are no upsells anywhere.

    Surfshark’s apps are built for convenience, too, with your VPN IP address and protocol right on the home screen and a ping you can check by hovering over each server. But Surfshark gives its best real estate to extras, while settings you actually need, like split tunneling and the kill switch, sit two pages deep.

    Billing and cancellation: A tie, but Surfshark is quicker

    Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, both paid up, and both earned the same billing score. Surfshark was the faster of the two. Its live chat agent sent us a link to a short questionnaire, and we were done in under five minutes.

    With PIA, we filed a support ticket and waited about a day for a reply. Once PIA got back to us, the refund came quickly, and it didn’t even make us give a reason. Neither app shows your full billing details, so you’ll need to log in through a browser to manage your subscription. Check out the step-by-step breakdown for cancellation below.

    SurfsharkPIA
    How to request a refundLive chat, then a short questionnaireSupport ticket or email
    Our reviewer's experienceDone in under five minutes, no issuesReply in about 24 hours, no reason required
    Refund timingDone in less than an hourAbout 8 hours after confirming

    Pro tip: Buy PIA directly from its website, since app store purchases don’t qualify for its money-back guarantee. With either VPN, log in through a browser before your renewal date so you know exactly what you’ll be charged.

    Final verdict for Surfshark vs. Private Internet Access: PIA wins!

    Yes, PIA wins overall, 85/100 to 74.7/100. It led on price, servers, speed, and apps, and tied Surfshark on billing, security, and devices. Surfshark didn’t win a single category outright.

    Surfshark is a strong pick if you want the fastest raw downloads, identity theft coverage, or a content blocker to keep the kids safe online. For everyone else, PIA gives you more VPN for less, without the upsells.

    Surfshark vs. Private Internet Access: FAQ

    Is Surfshark or PIA faster?

    Which is cheaper, Surfshark or PIA?

    Do Surfshark or PIA have a free plan?

    Can I use Surfshark or PIA for streaming?

    Disclaimers

    Author -

    Editor - Jessica Brooksby

    Jessica loves bringing her passion for the written word and her love of tech into one space at HighSpeedInternet.com. She works with the team’s writers to revise strong, user-focused content so every reader can find the tech that works for them. Jessica has a bachelor’s degree in English from Utah Valley University and seven years of creative and editorial experience. Outside of work, she spends her time gaming, reading, painting, and buying an excessive amount of Legend of Zelda merchandise.